I wandered around Classroom 2.0 for a while and feel like I have a good understanding of it. I was able to find a “middle school science” group which was discussing different ways of implementing web tools in the science classroom. Some members made helpful comments, but what was best were all the links to actual class websites or videos or blogs which both students and teachers had created. What was encouraging, too, were all the people who admitted they were newbies to incorporating technology in the classroom. The veterans seem so willing to help and offer their advice and share their experiences.
Ning in Education is easier to navigate than Classroom 2.0, mainly because it is smaller. (Classroom 2.0 was user friendly, just big.) It was easy to quickly find the “Middle School Science Teacher” group and follow the various discussions. Again, it seems very friendly and easy to use. There are a range of topics from technology in the classroom to good experiments and demonstations. (The creator of the group had a cute video on how to remember that density = mass/volume. If you draw a heart and divide it in half straight across it looks like “m” over “v”. ) Overall, it looks like a good group – real teachers in real classrooms with practical suggestions and inspirational videos. For me, it would be great to be able to ask this group questions and to just have the input of new ideas. I also explored the “Middle School” group. It wasn’t as exciting as the science group but still had some useful discussions in progress.
I think the Ning group could be used for great benefit in the classroom. I would probably start with a trial Ning with a group of interested students. If it worked well with the trial group then I would broaden it to include more. This would be for my science class to network about school – specifically about science. They could blog, upload videos, ask questions about classwork, homework, upload their own productions. One big advantage of a ning is that it would create a sense of community among my students. They would see school using a real-life application similar to facebook- although not nearly as elaborate. I think that would they would go for it! I read some teachers’ comments on nings for their classes. There may be an under age 12 restriction that would have to be investigated. Hopefully, that issue will be resolved before I’m back in the U.S. classroom. Also, a Ning network specific for science teachers in the county where I (will) work could be a great resource of ideas, questions and answers for all the teachers who have to cover the same curriculum using the same textbooks.